The smoke from the grill hung over the Whitaker backyard like dirty gauze, trapping the smell of charcoal, 's'lake water, and Gavin Reed’s expensive bourbon beneath it.
I stood near the cedar fence with a paper plate cooling in my hand, watching Gavin move through the crowd.
He had always been good at crowds.
He remembered names, slapped shoulders, refilled drinks before anyone asked. When Mrs. Talbot from across the street mentioned her bad knee, he leaned close and listened as though nothing in the world mattered more. When one of the school-board members arrived, Gavin hugged him with both arms and announced that the new football scoreboard had been “the least he could do for the kids.”
Everyone laughed.
Everyone loved him.
My seven-year-old daughter, Emma, sat cross-legged on the grass, building a castle from paper cups. Her dark hair kept falling into her face, and every few seconds she blew it aside with an irritated puff.
She had her mother’s eyes.
That was why I still attended Reed family gatherings four years after my wife, Laura, died.
Laura had been Gavin’s younger sister. She had loved summer cookouts, crowded kitchens, and family traditions. After the accident, I kept bringing Emma because I thought preserving those traditions might preserve something of her mother.
By then, I should have known better.
“You planning to eat that?”
Advertisements
I turned toward the voice.
An older man leaned against the fence several feet away. He was tall but narrow, with silver hair cut close to his scalp and forearms marked by pale scars. A half-full beer rested in his hand, though I had not seen him drink from it.
“I’m considering my options,” I said.
“Skip the potato salad. Been sitting in the sun since noon.”
I glanced at the glossy yellow mound on my plate. “Good intelligence.”
He held out his hand. “Walter Keene. Two houses down.”
“Daniel Mercer.”
His handshake was firm without becoming a performance.
Walter nodded toward Emma. “Your girl?”
“She is.”
“Good kid.”
“You’ve known her for twelve seconds.”
“I’m an excellent judge of paper-cup architecture.”
For the first time that afternoon, I smiled.
Walter’s eyes remained on the yard. Unlike the other guests, he did not seem relaxed. He noticed who entered through the side gate. He noticed when the music changed. He noticed that Gavin’s smile tightened whenever someone interrupted him.
I noticed Walter noticing.
Before I could ask what he had done before retirement, Emma abandoned her crooked castle and walked toward the dessert table.
She stopped in front of a tray of chocolate-chip cookies and rose onto her toes.
Gavin saw her.
“Hey. No.”
His voice cut through the conversation near the grill.
Emma froze with her fingers inches from a cookie.
“Those are for the guests,” Gavin said.
The people closest to him chuckled, assuming he was joking.
Emma looked around at the crowded yard. “I’m a guest.”
A second ripple of laughter followed.
That was when Gavin’s expression changed.
Only for half a second.
His smile remained in place, but something sharp moved behind his eyes. I had seen that look twice before—once when a waiter corrected his wine order, and once when Laura disagreed with him at Thanksgiving.
I started walking.
Gavin reached Emma before I did.
His fingers closed around her upper arm, and he jerked her away from the table.
Her sneakers left the grass.
Emma cried out.
